15 Best Mascaras for Older Women 2023: Top Picks

The content may contain affiliate links. we may earn a commission when you make a purchase. Our beauty and fashion articles offer guidance and tips, but individual results may vary. Know More

While we start aging, our eyes become smaller and wrinkled. Probably, you would need the best mascara for older women to look perfect. With the best-selected mascara to your rescue, you will gracefully start aging.

While you do makeup, the makeover of your eyes equally counts. The best mascara for mature women defines your eyes and gives the most voluminous look. Whether you want mascara for blonde eyelashes or vegan mascara, we have shortlisted the perfect ones for you. 

15 Best Mascaras for Older Women: Review 

1. Honest Beauty Extreme Mascara Length

What we love about Honest beauty’s extreme mascara is its primer feature. Not only does the best mascara for mature women give you an intensifying look but also acts as the perfect primer.

Best Mascara for Older Women

The award-winning mascara is made out of jojoba esters and is EWG certified. Stay true to your conscience as the best mascara for mature eyes is cruelty-free and completely authentic free from mineral oil, silicones, paraffin, and parabens. 

Best Mascara for Older Women

Specifications

  • Made in the USA.
  • The top ingredients are beeswax, potassium cetyl phosphate, cellulose, carnauba wax, glycerin jojoba esters, etc. 
  • Is certified by EWG. 
  • Free from artificial including parabens, paraffin, mineral oil, silicones, synthetic fragrances, etc. 

Pros

  • The built-in prime+ prep intensifies the performance. 
  • A long-wearing mascara. 
  • The wand is flexible and molded bristles that give evenly coats on the lashes. 

Cons

  • It’s not completely waterproof as the color fades with minimum watering. 

2. Gaya Best Vegan Mascara Drugstore 

For sensitive or mature eyelashes it’s always better to go with the best vegan mascara drugstore.

On one coating, you will get light or natural lashes, for 2-3 coatings it will give medium volume and 4-5 coatings are for intensified looks.

Best Mascara for Older Women

The Gaya mascaras are also the best mascara for blonde eyelashes because they offer color choices like blue and brown. Some of the effective results you will get are lengthening, curling, or defining outcomes. 

Specifications

  • The mascara is available in liquid format.
  • It’s cruelty-free and 100% vegan. 
  • For sensitive eyes, it’s ophthalmologist tested. 
  • Hypoallergenic and free of toxic chemicals. 
Best Mascara for Older Women

Pros

  • Have lengthening lashes without any clumps. 
  • Easily applicable and instant removal. 
  • Get controlled volume along with a curbed professional wand. 
  • Long-lasting. 

Cons

  • Users find it hard to remove as they get all smudged up. 
  • The blue mascara color does not produce the expected color transformation. 

3. L’Oréal Paris Makeup Original Mascara 

When you get old, there are chances that your lashes will fall off and you will have limited eyelashes. The L’Oréal Paris telescopic mascara intensifies the makeup with a bolder outcome.

Best Mascara for Older Women

The best mascara for mature women gives up to 60% telescopic extension without compromising the authentic impression.

The mascara does not include any fragrance and is suitable for sensitive eye types. Check the features of the best mascara for older women below.

Best Mascara for Older Women

Specifications

  • They are committed to a world free from animal testing for at least 30 years. 
  • It’s Ophthalmologist tested and does not react with contact lenses. 
  • Ingredients included are beeswax, stearic acid, cera alba, paraffin, hydrogenated palm oil, jojoba oil, etc. 
  • It’s a 60% more telescopic lengthening mascara. 

Pros

  • The wand is flexible and slim for easy application. 
  • Get clump-free lash-by-lash separate results. 
  • Intensifying extension mascara. 

Cons

  • Is not free from artificial substances like paraffin, titanium oxide, etc. 
  • The wand is not as flexible as they claim. 

4. ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara For Mature Women 

Ilia’s limitless best mascara for mature eyes comes in midnight black color which is also a clean formulation. The black mascara is 99% naturally derived and drifts your lashes with just the right amount.

Best Mascara for Older Women

Looking for alternatives to the best vegan mascara drugstore? Well, you better try out Ilia’s masterpiece. The limitless lash mascara is gluten, soy, or synthetic dye free.

You don’t have to feel nauseated by any strong scent as the mascara is free from any fragrance. 

Specifications

  • Safe for sensitive eyes and is ophthalmologist tested. 
  • The mascara formulation is 99% naturally derived and 25% organic. 
  • Ingredients like shea butter, beeswax, radish root ferment, and cornstarch are its perks. 
  • The mascara is free from animal cruelty. 

Pros

  • Have healthy-looking lashes with the right amount of volume added. 
  • Safer for contact lens wearers. 
  • Is lightweight and comes with a nourishing formula. 
  • Have buildable and flake-free lashes. 

Cons

  • The mascara is good but it gets clumped often. 

5. Ecco Bella FlowerColor Vegan Mascara 

There are many random brown mascaras you may find but they are not safe for your eyes. Such mascaras are typically irritating and not smudge-proof.

Best Mascara for Older Women

Ecco Bella flower color comes to your rescue with exclusive features like non-irritating, water-resistant, lengthening, and clump-free formula. The best mascara for blonde eyelashes has some extraordinary features, check out below. 

Specifications

  • Ecco Bella mascara is free from cruelty, paraben, gluten, and fragrance. 
  • Natural ingredients like natural clay, purified water, flower cutins, and carnauba wax. 
  • It’s one of the best vegan mascara drugstores. 
  • Comes in a mirror design tube. 

Pros

  • The eye mascara is a water-resistant formula free from smudges. 
  • Stays all day long. 
  • Protective and separating lengthy lashes. 
  • Have superior performance with professional brush coats.

Cons

  • The formulation is a bit watery and easily gets messy. 

6. Pacifica Aquarian Gaze Water Resistant Mascara 

Pacifica Water Resistant mascara is another best vegan mascara drugstore on our long list. The lengthening brush turns your lashes insanely gorgeous and long.

Best Mascara for Older Women

As the best mascara for older women, it is infused with coconut oil and vitamin B to give deep intensify color results.

The bristles of the brush are vegan molded and the wand is super flexible to use. Know more about the mascara below. 

Specifications

  • The material used is free from carmine, silicone, phthalate, and paraben. 
  • The black mascara is not animal tested. 
  • It’s clean, beautiful, and vegan. 
  • Infused with coconut oil, kelp extract, and vitamin B for hydrating impact. 

Pros

  • The long-length brush helps in easy application. 
  • Have an intensive deep black color. 
  • Uniquely separates and elongates lashes. 
  • Free from toxins like paraben, phthalate, and silicone. 

Cons

  • It turns out as clumpy eyelashes and is not completely waterproof.

7. Maybelline Sky High Washable Mascara

Firstly, before going to the mascara quality, we are obsessed with its exterior packaging. Available in a pink pretty container, Maybelline sky-high lash impact extends to limitless length.

Best Mascara for Older Women

It intensifies to darker results with full voluminous effects. While formulated with bamboo extract and full fibers it never weighs the lashes down. 

Specifications

  • Tested by ophthalmologist and suitable for contact lens wearers. 
  • Allergy tested. 
  • Comes with a flex brush for even application. 
Best Mascara for Older Women

Pros

  • The eyelashes don’t flake or smudge easily.
  • Is infused with bamboo extract and fibers for long wear.
  • Ingredients like stearic acid, palmitic acid, caprylic glycol, and potassium sorbate are included. 

Cons

  • The brush is neither rigid nor robbery-type flexible. 

8. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara 

It’s okay to style extraordinarily even at your mature age. Essence’s best mascara for mature eyes gives your eyes a false lash effect. The mascara is quite volumizing and arrives with a clinically shaped fiber brush.

Best Mascara for Older Women

Stay committed to the world as it’s not animal-treated and animal-byproduct-free. The false lashes effect mascara stays all day without any clumps or globs. 

Specifications

  • The material used for the mascara is free from paraben, alcohol, and animal byproduct. 
  • Not tested on animals. 
  • Gives false lash effects. 
  • It’s an unscented, best vegan mascara drugstore. 
Best Mascara for Older Women

Pros

  • The conic fiber brush captures every lash. 
  • Get clump or globs-free outcome. 
  • It stays for all-day with dramatic volume. 

Cons

  • Often the mascara gets smudged up which is not much liked. 

9. CoverGirl Lash Blast Brown Volume Mascara 

It’s hard to find the best mascara for blonde eyelashes with 10x extra precise results. CoverGirl mascaras are known for their nonflaking and non-clumping features.

Best Mascara for Older Women

Don’t hesitate to have an ultimate big lash look while applying the mascara. To get amplified results: first, curl the eyelashes. Then, apply a single coat of mascara to the upper lids, and reapply on the outer edges of the lash line to have added volume. 

Specifications

  • Cruelty-free certified product. 
  • The mega volume of fullness and added length. 
  • The mascara is in liquid form.
  • Ingredients included are carnauba wax, glycerol stearate, oleic acid, propylene glycol, etc.

Pros

  • The best mascara for blonde eyelashes comes with no clump brush. 
  • The mascara is hypoallergenic.
  • Max out every lash. 
  • The perfect volume-boosting formula. 

Cons

  • Maybe not be a  good option for sensitive eye types and some users find it itchy and irritating. 

10. Maydear Waterproof Long Lasting Color Mascara 

Maydear smudge-proof waterproof mascara is available in multiple color options and is well suited best mascara for blonde eyelashes.

Best Mascara for Older Women

The specialty of using the mascara is that it gives you the naturalistic look without overdoing eye makeup. The mascara suits every skin type and the color is formulated in such a way that it lasts and is not easy to take off. Have a long, dense lump free look. 

Specifications

  • The lashes extend up to two times the natural length. 
  • Get thicker and fuller eye makeup. 
  • The material used is nontoxic and liquid in format. 
  • Easily removable and free from smudges using warm water

Pros

  • The mascara is waterproof and smudge-proof. 
  • Precise coating where every eyelash can be seen clearly. 
  • More attractive and vivid color options. 

Cons

  • The mascara is less hydrating as after applying the eyes get dried out instantly. 
  • Not as easily removable as claimed. 

11. Lancôme Monsieur Big Volumizing Mascara 

The Lancôme Monsieur best mascara for older women appears with the most intuitively designed wand. The professionally designed brush gives twelve times more volumizing false lash effect.

Best Mascara for Older Women

The mascara is of creamy texture which does not let your eyelashes feel dried out and maintains the lightweight. The beauty formulation does not flake and is also smudge-proof. Features for the best mascara for mature women are below. 

Best Mascara for Older Women

Specifications

  • The ultra-black pigments make a 12 times extra volumizing impact. 
  • The item is in gel format. 
  • Have evenly applied with the wavy fiber bristle to build quick volume. 

Pros

  • The infused polymers and wax bring the best voluminous result. 
  • It has a super buildable texture. 
  • Staying for 24 hours long time.

Cons

  • Should have been more waterproof. 

12. Bobbi Brown Smokey Eye Mascara 

Bobby Brown Beauty has passionately offered the best beauty product ranges since 1992. The mascara is better suited for different skin tones across all ages.

Best Mascara for Older Women

The best mascara for mature eyes helps in building volume lash by lash. You don’t have to worry about the uneven finishing as it serves with the best clump-free silky finish ever.

The Bobbi brown best mascara for mature women is an apt eyewear kit to wear daily. 

Specifications

  • The mascara is made in Italy. 
  • Better suited for daily wear. 
  • Ingredients like chicory root extract, carnauba wax, sunflower seed wax, stearic acid, caesalpinia spinosa gum, and oleic acid are there. 
  • Suits different skin tones. 
  • Good for contact lens wearers.

Pros

  • The mascara is lightweight formulation and does not feel weary on daily use. 
  • It is non-clumping and flake-free. 
  • Good for people having eye allergies. 

Cons

  • It’s not a good product to wear on rainy days or while in swim shots. 

13. Primelash Best Mascara for Older Women 

With growing age, our skin becomes extra sensitive, so for that prime lash mascara is perfect. The product is professionally made to volumize, lengthen and separate the shorter lashes, which are the common problems in 50s and 60s.

Best Mascara for Older Women

The mascara is both sweat and water resistant and provides extra curl to the lashes. It has the potential to hold makeup and is not an easy deal to smudge.

Specifications

  • It has a neutral PH value and the ingredients are hypoallergenic.
  • For thinking lashes outcome, the brush head is slim.
  • The eye makeup formula is waterproof. 
  • Good for all skin tones. 

Pros

  • You can have curls without any clumps.
  • Desirable experience with eyelash growth serum.
  • Anti-aging and anti-wrinkling. 

Cons

  • The mascara fails to plump the largest effectively and only separates the lashes.
  • Takes a longer time to dry. 

14. Poppy Austin Organic Mascara 

Poppy Austin is another vegan organic best mascara for mature eyes made with Argan oil. The eye makeup product is handmade with affection and eco-friendly palm oil-free formula.

Best Mascara for Older Women

It’s a 100% registered vegan mascara with organic ingredients. For those having sensitive eyes or short lashes, stay assured as it is a ph balanced gentle formulation. The best mascara for older women is unscented and hypoallergenic. 

Specifications

  • Up to 8 times more gentle than chemically used mascaras.
  • 24 hours of moisture-rich coverage. 
  • It uses natural ingredients and is free from parabens, synthetics, and artificial fragrances. 
  • Not tested on animals. 

Pros

  • It is water-resistant and smudge and flake-free. 
  • Hydrates and has volumizing eyelashes. 
  • Gives instant longer, fuller and thicker lashes.

Cons

  • Even though the formula is good, the brush is quite mediocre comparatively. 

15. Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

Using Neutrogena lashes will guarantee you 100% longer lash results. The gentle bristle brush allows you to apply the mascara evenly on each lash.

Best Mascara for Older Women

You don’t have to worry about clumps, smudging, or flakes while using the mascara. You can also easily remove the mascara using water or Neutrogena oil-free makeup remover. 

Specifications

  • Consists of ingredients like vitamin E and olive oil for healthy-looking lashes. 
  • Is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact wearers. 
  • Tested by ophthalmologists. 

Pros

  • The soft bristles evenly comb through every lash from root to tip. 
  • Gives 100% longer eyelashes. 
  • Infused with the natural goodness of olive oil and vitamin E.

Cons

  • The lashes flake a lot post applying. 

How To Choose Mascara Color? 

To complete your eye makeup, you must choose the best mascara for mature eyes of all eye colors.

While for pale eyes, you can also wear brown or light mascaras, and for darker eyelashes, you can wear black ones. Here are some tips for choosing your mascara color: 

Best Mascara for Older Women
  • When it comes to black mascara, it suits all eyelashes and skin tones. While you wear black mascara, try curling the lashes first to make them look longer. 
  • Pick brown mascaras when you have a lighter skin tone or when you want a natural look. 
  • For brown mascaras, try to apply those eyeshadows or eyeliners which are not darker than the mascara. 
  • Those who have rare brown or gray eyes can experiment with blue or purple mascaras. Such a choice will turn to a more statement look. 

Now below have a gaze at the best mascara for blonde eyelashes or black lashes that will give you a more naturalistic appearance. 

Have Beautiful Eyes for All Ages! 

So, above we have discussed the best mascara for older women available at the most affordable price ranges.

Best Mascara for Older Women

While most of the mascara is ophthalmologist-approved, in case you have sensitive skin types or other issues, it’s safer to not use it daily. Try the vegan mascaras to stay true to Mother Nature. 

FAQs:

1. What is the best mascara for seniors? 

The best mascara for seniors are those that are more volumizing, intensive, and lightweight. Try those that are ophthalmologist-tested to prevent itchiness or irritation. Try out our picks like Essissenils Primelash Best Mascara for Older Women; Gaya Best Vegan Mascara Drugstore for Sensitive Eyes; Lancôme Monsieur Big Volumizing Mascara.

2. What Colour mascara should older women wear?

The color an older woman should wear depends on her liking, skin tone, and lash color. Other than the obvious black mascara, you can try out brown or blue ones for blonde lashes.

See the above mascaras like Gaya Best Vegan Mascara Drugstore for Sensitive Eyes; Ecco Bella FlowerColor Vegan Plant-Based Mascara; Maydear Waterproof Long Lasting Color Mascara. 

3. What mascara makes your eyes look bigger?

Eye mascaras that promise long lashes can make your eyes look bigger. Some volumizing and fake effect lash mascaras are also good for that purpose. Try out Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara; and Lancôme Monsieur Big Volumizing Mascara

4. How can I make my eyes look bigger when older?

By wearing the best volumizing, long-wear elongated eye mascara you can make your eyes look bigger when older. Wear mascaras like L’Oréal Paris Makeup  Original Lengthening Telescopic Mascara; Essissenils Primelash Best Mascara for Older Women and Poppy Austin Organic Mascara for telescopic longer lashes.

5. How do you apply mascara to mature eyes?

To have amplified and intensified results, first, curl your lashes. Then, apply one coat of mascara to the upper lids, and reapply on the outer edges of the lash line to have observable volume. 

Also Read: Complete Guide about How To Clean Eyelash Extension with Products

Also Read: Top 15 Cool-Toned Eyeshadow Palettes in 2023: Get Perfect Look

About Author /

Mouli Chakraborty is your trusted guide to all things beauty and hair with five years of experience in this area. Through her content, she tries to share contemporary fashion statements and brings to her readers trendy style ideas that know no age, color, or other bounds. Mouli also honestly reviews relevant skincare and haircare branded products, to help readers make informed and best choices. She loves to experiment with vintage, freestyle, and minimalist stylish looks and misses no chance to reflect her preference through her writings.

Start typing and press Enter to search